Zgrabik is one of the most decorated FGCU softball players of the Division I era. She was the 2013 ASUN Player of the Year, a three-time NFCA All-Region selection and a two-time First Team All-ASUN performer (2012, 2014) and was named Second Team All-ASUN after her 2013 season was cut short due to injury. Zgrabik was later named to the ASUN All-Decade Team. Her 42 career home runs and 153 career RBI both rank No. 1 in FGCU's Division I era and are No. 3 all-time. Defensively, Zgrabik threw out 16 of 24 potential base-stealers from her catcher position. She also holds the FGCU career record for pickoffs with 7. Zgrabik was a key part of the 2012 ASUN Regular Season and Tournament Championship teams. She and the Eagles earned the school's first-ever win of any kind in an NCAA Tournament with a victory over Florida at the Gainesville Regional in 2012. Zgrabik graduated in 2014 with a B.A. in Psychology. She is now a registered nurse at Sarasota Memorial Hospital.