Sophomore (2024) at FSW: Helped the Bucs to back-to-back national championship titles. She made the All-Tournament team and led the NJCAA in hitting percentage and blocks per set.

Freshman (2023) at FSW: Played in 11 matches for the National Champs last season, averaging 1.55 kills and 1.09 blocks per set while leading the team with a .525 hitting percentage.  She recorded her first career kill in a 3-0 FSW sweep over Central Wyoming on opening weekend and two weeks later, had the best game of her rookie campaign, finishing off 8 kills on just 11 swings, good for a .727 hitting percentage in a win over Coastal Alabama. She had her best match in Citrus Conference play in the Bucs final regular season match of the year, dialing up 6 kills and career high 5 blocks in a 3-0 sweep of Indian River.  

High School: Won a pair of State Championships inside of Suncoast Credit Union Arena while at Lake Worth Christian High School.  She was a four time All-County selection for the Defenders and was a two time finalist for the Palm Beach Post Player of the Year. Toeniskoetter put up eye popping numbers during her high school career, finishing with 1,115 kills, 425 blocks, and 71 aces while hitting .473 during her career.  As a senior in 2022 she led the state of Florida in kills with 463 and blocks with 114.  Also a stand out in the classroom, Toeniskoetter won a number of academic awards during her time at LWCHS including being a member of the National Honors Society and Presidents Honor Roll while also being her class Valedictorian. Toeniskoetter also had success on the club circut where she won a pair of National Championships playing for the Palm Beach Juniors. 

Personal: Born May 8, 2005...Daughter of Jeff and Stacy Toeniskoetter and has one sister, Hanna.