Recognizes the annual top overall female and male FGCU athlete, as collectively deemed by the coaching and administrative staff. The award is presented at the Welcome Back picnic each August.

 

Eagles Club Most Outstanding Athlete Award
Year	Women's Recipient	Sport	Year	Men's Recipient	Sport
2023	TK Morehouse	Basketball	2023	Edrick Felix	Baseball
				Magnus Johnson	Tennis
2022	Kierstan Bell	Basketball	2022	Alejandro Figueredo	Baseball
				Magnus Johnson	Tennis
2021	Kierstan Bell	Basketball	2021	Van Holmgren	Golf
	Petra Halmai	Swimming
2020	Evdokia Popadinova	Soccer	2020	O'Vonte Mullings	Soccer
	Keri Jewett-Giles	Basketball
2019	Evdokia Popadinova	Soccer	2019	Preston Kilwien	Soccer
	Cortney VanLiew	Volleyball
	Nasrin Ulel	Basketball
2018	Ashley Parks	Soccer	2018	Brandon Goodwin	Basketball
	Amanda Carroll	Volleyball
2017	Tabby Tindell	Soccer	2017	Albert Ruiz	Soccer
2016	Whitney Knight	Basketball	2016	Jake Noll	Baseball
2015	Emma Svensson	Swimming & Diving	2015	Jordi Vives	Tennis
	Tabby Tindell	Soccer		Nick Rivera	Baseball
	Whitney Knight	Basketball
2014	Kira Toussaint	Swimming & Diving	2014	Mike Murray	Baseball
	Kelly Perzanowski	Cross Country		Jordi Vives	Tennis
2013	Sarah Hansen	Basketball	2013	Sherwood Brown	Basketball
2012	Sarah Hansen	Basketball	2012	Ricky Knapp	Baseball
2011	Shannon Murphy	Basketball	2011	Adam Glick	Soccer
	Courtney Platt	Softball
2010	Chelsea Lyles	Basketball	2010	Chris Sale	Baseball
2009	Cheyenne Jenks	Softball	2009	Josh Upchurch	Baseball
2008	Carmen Paez	Softball	2008	Jason Peacock	Baseball
2007	Kate Schrader	Basketball	2007	Beau Bauer	Basketball
2006	Kate Schrader	Basketball	2006	Jason Louwsma	Baseball
				Juan Carlos Osorio	Tennis
2005	Kelly Powe	Softball	2005	Richard Stempnowski	Tennis
				Bryan Crislip	Basketball
2004	Kelly Powe	Softball	2004	Leighton Bowie	Basketball
2003	Trish Fleming	Basketball	2003	Chris Brown	Baseball